BuyersGuide.org is an independent, advertising-supported comparison website. Products and services that appear on BuyersGuide.org are from companies from which BuyersGuide.org receives compensation. This compensation may impact the location and order in which these products appear.
BuyersGuide.org takes into consideration a number of proprietary rules to determine how and where products appear on the site. BuyersGuide.org does not include the entire universe of available product choices.
About Our Rankings
Our editors rate and review products objectively based on the features offered to consumers, the price and delivery options, how a product compares with other products in its category, and other factors.
The ratings are based on the expert opinion of our editors and on underlying technology that analyzes decisions made by similar users to provide individual, targeted recommendations to each person who visits our site.
Join the millions that have trusted BuyersGuide.org to help them make smarter buying decisions. Let our independent expert reviews and data-driven shopping recommendations help you find the mattress topper that's right for you.
Compare the best-rated mattress toppers based on price, performance, power, efficiency, and user experience and get the best mattress topper for your home!
Helping Millions of Users Make Smarter Purchases Online.
Choosing The Best Option
What goes into being the best, you may ask. The criteria we've looked at include:
Shopping Guide: Mattress Toppers
You might be sitting at work dreaming about sleeping on a cloud. As soon as you punch out, you could be making that dream a reality.
If you’ve had a mattress for a few years, you may have noticed a slight sag where you normally sleep. While your bed might still be soft and dreamy, this saggy spot won’t exactly give you the support that your body needs to thoroughly enjoy a full night’s sleep.
In fact, you might even start to notice a difference in your energy levels as you go through your day. Gradually, you could start requiring more and more cups of coffee in the mornings until you’re guzzling whole thermoses without realizing it.
It’s hard to face the truth of needing a new bed, especially when costs can reach close to $1,000 for that miracle mattress.
We’re here to grab you by the tired shoulders, look you squarely in the eyes, and tell you that you can find this same miracle sleep without spending more than $200. You could even find the ideal sleep for under $100...with fewer daily Starbucks visits, this investment will pay for itself in no time.
All you need is a new mattress topper.
Tempur-Pedic™ Feel Without Tempur-Pedic™ Price
Remember those commercials where a glass of wine would be placed delicately on one side of the mattress while someone haphazardly jumped up and down on the other side of the bed?
Every viewer was captivated with this magic trick, and it seemed like these mattresses were something out of a futuristic film. Not only did the technology seem out of this world, but the price was also astronomical.
It’s been 26 years since Tempur-Pedic™ brought their space-age mattress technology to the forefront, and in that time, sleep design has evolved for the everyday budget.
What to Look for in a Mattress Topper
You don’t need to balance a glass of wine on your mattress topper to test it out. Instead, you just need to keep your eye out for a few notable differences between options.
First thing’s first, make sure you know the size of the bed you’re shopping for. This may seem like a common sense rule, but there’s nothing worse than being genuinely excited for a gift only to be thwarted by the wrong size.
Each mattress topper will be specified for a certain size of bed.
Mattress topper depth will also determine if you need sheets with deeper pockets. For instance, toppers can range from 4” thick to 2” thick. Some are cut shorter at the edges to accommodate for your current bed sheets while others will push the limits of your fitted sheets.
While we wouldn’t encourage this to be a deciding factor in your shopping journey, this is something to consider if you don’t have the budget for more pocketed sheets. Along with this, if the bed you’re fitting with a mattress topper sits in a loft or low clearance room, a couple of inches could make a huge difference in terms of hitting your head on the ceiling or not.
You don’t need to get a thick mattress topper to get quality comfort. With innovative materials and fill, thinner mattress toppers make up the majority of our top picks.
Staying Cool is Key
All of our top picks have been specially designed to keep users cool and ventilated throughout the night. Rather than packing in a dense amount of materials into their fill, they’ve manufactured models that breathe.
Each model does this differently, whether it’s through a cooling gel or Egg Crate technology. Since there is no set scale or chart of how many degrees each topper cools you down, user reviews prove to be the most useful in determining just how cool each mattress topper makes you.
Based on user reference, ExceptionalSheets takes the cake when offering a breeze-like topper that moves air through its material rather than trapping it.
With a product that is touching your skin for 8 hours or more a night, a mattress topper needs to have materials that accommodate allergies and sensitive skin. For sleepers that have had issues with allergies and reactions to their sleeping arrangements, make sure you look for mattress toppers that use hypoallergenic fill in their products.
Certified to Help you Sleep Better
There is no better way to guarantee you’re getting a top-quality mattress topper than to see if it’s certified by reputable grading scales. In this case, the options that are CertiPUR-US certified get one step up from their competition.
The CertiPUR-US program is a non-profit that started in 2008 with the mission to inspect and verify the quality of foam used in bedding and upholstery. This program began with the hopes to prevent foam from being made from environmentally damaging chemicals or those that failed performance tests.
When a mattress topper is CertiPUR-US certified, you can rely on the durability, performance, and safety of the materials in the product, giving you peace of mind as you dip deeper into that end-of-the-week slumber.
Last but not Least: Price
So if you’re wanting to save money by keeping your old mattress, then price and affordability are huge factors in this decision.
Lucky for you, you don’t have to struggle with a wide berth of price ranges. Our top picks range from around $70 to under $200, keeping the price variable simple. At the most affordable price on the scale, you can still find a solution that relieves pressure points and takes away the discomfort of an unsupportive mattress. Once you step up in price, you’ll typically find that airier materials are used to keep sleepers cooler.
Or, you’ll start to see a distinction in thread count, fill distribution, hypoallergenic materials, and more. We’ve pointed out these differences in our top 10 picks to make it easier for you to compare and save.
Now it’s up to you to upgrade that mattress of yours! Don’t you dare take out more than $300 for this unless you’re prepared to get a new bed. We suggest trying out a mattress topper and seeing if that improves your slumber. Since most options have a nice little warranty or guarantee to go with them, it can’t hurt to see if this is the root of your troubles. Compare the top 10 mattress toppers today, and get to snoozin’.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Stay in the loop. Sign up today!