Best Creamy Eyeliner Pencils Updated May 2025
Advertiser disclosure About our rankings

Join the millions that have trusted BuyersGuide.org to help them make smarter buying decisions. Let our independent expert reviews and data-driven shopping recommendations help you find the one that's right for you.

Best Creamy Eyeliner Pencils
2025 Buyer's GuideUpdated May 2025
Advertiser disclosure About our rankings
Sort by:
Best Creamy Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1

9.9

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil - Frappe (Chocolate Brown)
Color
Ease of application
Value for money
Texture
Works well
Brightness
Best Creamy Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil - Frappe (Chocolate Brown)
Color
Ease of application
Value for money
Texture
Works well
Brightness

9.7

2

9.7

wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish Ve...
Color
Value for money
Quality
Ease of application
Glide
Works well
Save 17%
Save 17%

9.7

2
wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish Ve...
Color
Value for money
Quality
Ease of application
Glide
Works well
Save 17%

9.6

3

9.6

Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, Glide on Smooth Gel Pigments with 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof, B...
Color
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Save 6% + 15% Coupon
Save 6% + 15% Coupon

9.6

3
Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, Glide on Smooth Gel Pigments with 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof, B...
Color
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Save 6% + 15% Coupon

9.4

4

9.4

Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Long-Wearing, Ultra-Smooth, Smudge-Proof, 001, Black, 0.04oz
Longevity
Eyeliner quality
Pigmentation
Ease of application
Glide
Save 12%
Save 12%

9.4

4
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Long-Wearing, Ultra-Smooth, Smudge-Proof, 001, Black, 0.04oz
Longevity
Eyeliner quality
Pigmentation
Ease of application
Glide
Save 12%

9.3

5

9.3

wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Gel Eyeliner - Waterproof 16-Hour Long-Lasting Wear, Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Bric...
Ease of application
Value for money
Eyeliner quality
Pigmentation
Functionality
Save 43%
Save 43%

9.3

5
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Gel Eyeliner - Waterproof 16-Hour Long-Lasting Wear, Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Bric...
Ease of application
Value for money
Eyeliner quality
Pigmentation
Functionality
Save 43%
Premium Pick

9.2

6

9.2

Kaely 2Pcs Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Natural Black Eyeliner Cream for Waterline, Liquid Eye Liner Waterproof Smudge Proof, Black Smo...
Ease of application
Color
Glide
Premium Pick

9.2

6
Kaely 2Pcs Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Natural Black Eyeliner Cream for Waterline, Liquid Eye Liner Waterproof Smudge Proof, Black Smo...
Ease of application
Color
Glide

9.1

7

9.1

L'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge-Resistant, Waterproof Eye Makeup with Up to 36HR Wear, Bro...
Ease of application
Color
Eyeliner quality
Longevity
Glides on
Eye brightness
Save 33% + 15% Coupon
Save 33% + 15% Coupon

9.1

7
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge-Resistant, Waterproof Eye Makeup with Up to 36HR Wear, Bro...
Ease of application
Color
Eyeliner quality
Longevity
Glides on
Eye brightness
Save 33% + 15% Coupon
Best Value

9.0

8

9.0

wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish V...
Eyeliner quality
Value for money
Color quality
Ease of application
Glides on smoothly
Longevity
Save 17%
Save 17%
Best Value

9.0

8
wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish V...
Eyeliner quality
Value for money
Color quality
Ease of application
Glides on smoothly
Longevity
Save 17%
Popular

8.6

9

8.6

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof, Eye Makeup with Built-In Sharpener, 202 Black Brown, 0.01 oz
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Color
Save 27% + 25% Coupon
Save 27% + 25% Coupon
Popular

8.6

9
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof, Eye Makeup with Built-In Sharpener, 202 Black Brown, 0.01 oz
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Color
Save 27% + 25% Coupon

8.3

10

8.3

e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free,...
Ease of application
Value for money
Eyeliner quality
Stays on well
Color

8.3

10
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free,...
Ease of application
Value for money
Eyeliner quality
Stays on well
Color

Our Top Choice

Best Creamy Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1

9.9

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil - Frappe (Chocolate Brown)
Color
Ease of application
Value for money
Texture
Works well
Brightness
Best Creamy Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil - Frappe (Chocolate Brown)
Color
Ease of application
Value for money
Texture
Works well
Brightness
Related Categories
Creamy EyelinerGel EyelinerEye Pencil EyelinerDark EyelinerEyeshadow LinerEyeliner Gel
How We Rank
Expert Analysis
Our team of experts highlights useful information so you can easily compare products to find the one that's right for you.

Award-Winning Tech
Our technology analyzes thousands of purchase trends to bring you the top product recommendations.

Why Trust Our Reviews?
1,000,000+ shoppers use Buyer's Guide every week to find the best products and services online.

Learn more about our rankings.

Reliable, Safe & Secure
Helping millions of users make smarter purchases online.
Related Categories
Creamy EyelinerGel EyelinerEye Pencil EyelinerDark EyelinerEyeshadow LinerEyeliner Gel
Related Categories
Creamy EyelinerGel EyelinerEye Pencil EyelinerDark EyelinerEyeshadow LinerEyeliner Gel