Best Color Eyeliner Pencils Updated May 2025
Advertiser disclosure About our rankings

Join the millions that have trusted BuyersGuide.org to help them make smarter buying decisions. Let our independent expert reviews and data-driven shopping recommendations help you find the one that's right for you.

Best Color Eyeliner Pencils
2025 Buyer's GuideUpdated May 2025
Advertiser disclosure About our rankings
Sort by:
Best Color Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1

9.9

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil - Turquoise Storm
Color
Longevity
Ease of application
Save 33% + 15% Coupon
Save 33% + 15% Coupon
Best Color Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil - Turquoise Storm
Color
Longevity
Ease of application
Save 33% + 15% Coupon

9.8

2

9.8

MAYBELLINE Tattoo Studio Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof, Tealtini, 1 Count
Color quality
Ease of application
Lasted time
Eyeliner quality
Smudge resistance

9.8

2
MAYBELLINE Tattoo Studio Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof, Tealtini, 1 Count
Color quality
Ease of application
Lasted time
Eyeliner quality
Smudge resistance

9.5

3

9.5

15 Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, Eye Shadow Pencil, Pearl Eyeliner Kit Metallic Glitter Colored Eye liner for Women Eye&Lip Liner ...
Pigmentation
Value for money
Ease of application
Texture
Eyeliner quality
Work well
Save 10%
Save 10%

9.5

3
15 Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, Eye Shadow Pencil, Pearl Eyeliner Kit Metallic Glitter Colored Eye liner for Women Eye&Lip Liner ...
Pigmentation
Value for money
Ease of application
Texture
Eyeliner quality
Work well
Save 10%

9.4

4

9.4

evpct 12Pcs Green Blue White Black Brown Purple Color Gel Glitter Eyeliner Pencils Set for Women Waterline Waterproof Smudge Pr...
Color variety
Ease of application

9.4

4
evpct 12Pcs Green Blue White Black Brown Purple Color Gel Glitter Eyeliner Pencils Set for Women Waterline Waterproof Smudge Pr...
Color variety
Ease of application

9.3

5

9.3

15 Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, Shadow Pencil, Pearl Eyeliner Kit Metallic Glitter Eyeliner for Women Eye&Lip Liner Professional ...
Color variety
Value for money
Smooth application
Save 10%
Save 10%

9.3

5
15 Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, Shadow Pencil, Pearl Eyeliner Kit Metallic Glitter Eyeliner for Women Eye&Lip Liner Professional ...
Color variety
Value for money
Smooth application
Save 10%

9.2

6

9.2

Eye Liner Pencil Set - 12 Assorted Colors Natural Matte Long Lasting Hypoallergenic Eyeliners Eye Makeup Soft Crayon Pencils (B...
Color variety
Value for money

9.2

6
Eye Liner Pencil Set - 12 Assorted Colors Natural Matte Long Lasting Hypoallergenic Eyeliners Eye Makeup Soft Crayon Pencils (B...
Color variety
Value for money

9.1

7

9.1

12 Colors Eyeliner Set - Matte Colored Gel Eyeliner Pencils, Waterproof, Smudge-Proof, Long-Lasting Gel Pencils - Natural Eye L...
Color variety
Eye color
Smooth application
Ease of application
Brightness

9.1

7
12 Colors Eyeliner Set - Matte Colored Gel Eyeliner Pencils, Waterproof, Smudge-Proof, Long-Lasting Gel Pencils - Natural Eye L...
Color variety
Eye color
Smooth application
Ease of application
Brightness
Best Value
Popular

9.0

8

9.0

wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish V...
Eyeliner quality
Value for money
Color quality
Ease of application
Glides on smoothly
Longevity
Save 17%
Save 17%
Best Value
Popular

9.0

8
wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish V...
Eyeliner quality
Value for money
Color quality
Ease of application
Glides on smoothly
Longevity
Save 17%

8.9

9

8.9

L.A. Colors Eyeliner Pencil Black .035oz
Value for money
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Pigmentation
Functionality
Ease of removal

8.9

9
L.A. Colors Eyeliner Pencil Black .035oz
Value for money
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Pigmentation
Functionality
Ease of removal
Premium Pick

8.8

10

8.8

BONNIE CHOICE 20 PCS Colored Eyeliners Pencil Set, 20 Colors Waterproof Long Lasting Retractable Matte Colorful Eyeliner Milti-...
Color pigment
Value for money
Ease of application
Makeup effectiveness
Waterproof
Glide
Save 5%
Save 5%
Premium Pick

8.8

10
BONNIE CHOICE 20 PCS Colored Eyeliners Pencil Set, 20 Colors Waterproof Long Lasting Retractable Matte Colorful Eyeliner Milti-...
Color pigment
Value for money
Ease of application
Makeup effectiveness
Waterproof
Glide
Save 5%

Our Top Choice

Best Color Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1

9.9

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil - Turquoise Storm
Color
Longevity
Ease of application
Save 33% + 15% Coupon
Save 33% + 15% Coupon
Best Color Eyeliner Pencil

9.9

1
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil - Turquoise Storm
Color
Longevity
Ease of application
Save 33% + 15% Coupon
Related Categories
Eyeliner for Deep Set EyesGlitter Eyeliner PencilColor Eyeliner for Hazel EyesAffordable EyelinerTeal EyelinerMetallic Eyeliner
How We Rank
Expert Analysis
Our team of experts highlights useful information so you can easily compare products to find the one that's right for you.

Award-Winning Tech
Our technology analyzes thousands of purchase trends to bring you the top product recommendations.

Why Trust Our Reviews?
1,000,000+ shoppers use Buyer's Guide every week to find the best products and services online.

Learn more about our rankings.

Reliable, Safe & Secure
Helping millions of users make smarter purchases online.
Related Categories
Eyeliner for Deep Set EyesGlitter Eyeliner PencilColor Eyeliner for Hazel EyesAffordable EyelinerTeal EyelinerMetallic Eyeliner
Related Categories
Eyeliner for Deep Set EyesGlitter Eyeliner PencilColor Eyeliner for Hazel EyesAffordable EyelinerTeal EyelinerMetallic Eyeliner