Best All-Natural Eyeliners Updated May 2025
Advertiser disclosure About our rankings

Join the millions that have trusted BuyersGuide.org to help them make smarter buying decisions. Let our independent expert reviews and data-driven shopping recommendations help you find the one that's right for you.

Best All-Natural Eyeliners
2025 Buyer's GuideUpdated May 2025
Advertiser disclosure About our rankings
Sort by:
Best All-Natural Eyeliner

9.9

1

9.9

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black - 0.04 Ounce
Color
Ease of application
Eye irritation
Softness
Glide
Save 18%
Save 18%
Best All-Natural Eyeliner

9.9

1
Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black - 0.04 Ounce
Color
Ease of application
Eye irritation
Softness
Glide
Save 18%

9.8

2

9.8

Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner Pencil in Jet Set Black, Rich Pigmentation, Smooth, Long-Wearing, Vegan, Gluten-Free
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Eye irritation
Smoothness
Sturdiness
Color quality

9.8

2
Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner Pencil in Jet Set Black, Rich Pigmentation, Smooth, Long-Wearing, Vegan, Gluten-Free
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Eye irritation
Smoothness
Sturdiness
Color quality

9.6

3

9.6

Tatsat Ayurvedic herbal Kajal | Natural, Lead-Free & Chemical-Free Eye Care | Soothing Formula for Everyday Use | Safe for All ...
Longevity
Color accuracy
Eye color
Natural ingredients
Ease of application
Texture

9.6

3
Tatsat Ayurvedic herbal Kajal | Natural, Lead-Free & Chemical-Free Eye Care | Soothing Formula for Everyday Use | Safe for All ...
Longevity
Color accuracy
Eye color
Natural ingredients
Ease of application
Texture

9.5

4

9.5

Physicians Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eyeliner Pencil Ultra Black | Dermatologist Tested, Clinicially Tested
Eyeliner quality
Glide on
Ease of application
Save 5%
Save 5%

9.5

4
Physicians Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eyeliner Pencil Ultra Black | Dermatologist Tested, Clinicially Tested
Eyeliner quality
Glide on
Ease of application
Save 5%
Premium Pick

9.4

5

9.4

ILIA - Clean Line Gel Liner | Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Highly Pigmented + Water Resistant with Attached Sharpener (Twili...
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Sturdiness
Color accuracy
Glide
Irritation
Premium Pick

9.4

5
ILIA - Clean Line Gel Liner | Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Highly Pigmented + Water Resistant with Attached Sharpener (Twili...
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Sturdiness
Color accuracy
Glide
Irritation

9.3

6

9.3

Gabriel Cosmetics Classic Eyeliner (Black), Natural Eye Liner, Paraben Free, Vegan, Gluten-free, Cruelty- free, Non GMO, long l...
Color
Eyeliner quality
Softness
Allergen content
Glide

9.3

6
Gabriel Cosmetics Classic Eyeliner (Black), Natural Eye Liner, Paraben Free, Vegan, Gluten-free, Cruelty- free, Non GMO, long l...
Color
Eyeliner quality
Softness
Allergen content
Glide
Best Value
Popular

9.2

7

9.2

Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Hypoallergenic, Cruelty-Free, Smudge-Proof, Ophthalmologist Tested, Long Wearing and Water Resis...
Color
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Eye sensitivity
Functionality
Save 27% + 25% Coupon
Save 27% + 25% Coupon
Best Value
Popular

9.2

7
Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Hypoallergenic, Cruelty-Free, Smudge-Proof, Ophthalmologist Tested, Long Wearing and Water Resis...
Color
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Eye sensitivity
Functionality
Save 27% + 25% Coupon

9.1

8

9.1

Honest Beauty Longlasting Liquid Eyeliner | Smudge + Flake Proof, Precise Application | Hypoallergenic, Vegan, + Cruelty Free |...
Ease of application
Color pigment
Eyeliner quality
10% Coupon
10% Coupon

9.1

8
Honest Beauty Longlasting Liquid Eyeliner | Smudge + Flake Proof, Precise Application | Hypoallergenic, Vegan, + Cruelty Free |...
Ease of application
Color pigment
Eyeliner quality
10% Coupon

9.0

9

9.0

Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil, Black Eyeliner with Soothing Chamomile, Meadowfoam & Vitamin E, Velvety Smooth, Hypoallergenic Eye M...
Color
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Quality
Eye irritation
Longevity
Save 33%
Save 33%

9.0

9
Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil, Black Eyeliner with Soothing Chamomile, Meadowfoam & Vitamin E, Velvety Smooth, Hypoallergenic Eye M...
Color
Ease of application
Eyeliner quality
Quality
Eye irritation
Longevity
Save 33%

8.6

10

8.6

Wonderskin 1440 Longwear Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Sharpenable Black Eyeliner Pencil and Smudge Proof Eye Liner Pencil...
Longevity
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Color quality
Stay on
Glide
Save 21%
Save 21%

8.6

10
Wonderskin 1440 Longwear Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Sharpenable Black Eyeliner Pencil and Smudge Proof Eye Liner Pencil...
Longevity
Eyeliner quality
Ease of application
Color quality
Stay on
Glide
Save 21%

Our Top Choice

Best All-Natural Eyeliner

9.9

1

9.9

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black - 0.04 Ounce
Color
Ease of application
Eye irritation
Softness
Glide
Save 18%
Save 18%
Best All-Natural Eyeliner

9.9

1
Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black - 0.04 Ounce
Color
Ease of application
Eye irritation
Softness
Glide
Save 18%
Related Categories
Non-Toxic EyelinerVegan EyelinerEye Pencil EyelinerNo Smudge Eyeliner PencilSmudge Free EyelinerWater Based Eyeliner
How We Rank
Expert Analysis
Our team of experts highlights useful information so you can easily compare products to find the one that's right for you.

Award-Winning Tech
Our technology analyzes thousands of purchase trends to bring you the top product recommendations.

Why Trust Our Reviews?
1,000,000+ shoppers use Buyer's Guide every week to find the best products and services online.

Learn more about our rankings.

Reliable, Safe & Secure
Helping millions of users make smarter purchases online.
Related Categories
Non-Toxic EyelinerVegan EyelinerEye Pencil EyelinerNo Smudge Eyeliner PencilSmudge Free EyelinerWater Based Eyeliner
Related Categories
Non-Toxic EyelinerVegan EyelinerEye Pencil EyelinerNo Smudge Eyeliner PencilSmudge Free EyelinerWater Based Eyeliner