Top 10 Car Seats 2019

Join the millions that have trusted BuyersGuide.org to help them make smarter buying decisions. Let our independent expert reviews and data-driven shopping recommendations help you find the car seat that's right for you.

Compare the best-rated car seats based on price, performance, power, efficiency, and user experience and get the best car seat for your home!


Graco

9.8
Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 65 lb max weight
  • 6-position recline
  • Simply Safe Adjust harness
  • Weighs 24 lbs

Britax

9.7
Britax Frontier ClickTight Car Seat

  • Forward-facing
  • 120 lb max weight
  • 9-position recline
  • Harness-2-booster seat
  • Weighs 25 lbs

Evenflo

9.6
Evenflo Symphony Elite All-In-One Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 110 lb max weight
  • Multiple-position recline
  • 5-point harness
  • Weighs 24 lbs

Graco

9.5
Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 20 lb max weight
  • 6-position recline
  • 5-point harness
  • Weighs 22.8 lbs

Safety 1st

9.4
Safety 1st Grow and Go 3-in-1 Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 100 lbs max weight
  • 3-position recline
  • QuickFit Harness
  • Weighs 18.7 lbs

Graco

9.3
Graco Nautilus 3-in-1 Harness Booster Car Seat

  • Forward-facing
  • 100 lb max weight
  • 3-position recline
  • 5-point harness
  • Weighs 20.52 lbs

Safety 1st

9.2
Safety 1st Guide 65 Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 65 lb max weight
  • Non-recline
  • 5-point harness
  • Weighs 15 lbs

Graco

9.1
Graco Sequence 65 Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 65 lb max weight
  • 6-position recline
  • Simply Safe Adjust harness
  • Weighs 19.29 lbs

Evenflo

8.9
Evenflo SureRide Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 65 lb max weight
  • Multiple-position recline
  • 5-point harness
  • Weighs 9.8 lbs

Maxi-Cosi

8.8
Maxi-Cosi Infant Car Seat With Base

  • Rear-facing
  • 30 lb max weight
  • Non-recline
  • 5-point harness
  • Weighs 18.6 lbs

Britax

0.0
Britax Boulevard ClickTight Anti-Rebound Bar Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 65 max weight
  • 7-position recline
  • 14-position harness
  • Weighs 33.2 lbs

Our Top Choice



Graco

9.8
Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat

  • Forward and rear-facing
  • 65 lb max weight
  • 6-position recline
  • Simply Safe Adjust harness
  • Weighs 24 lbs
Trusted, Safe & Secure

Helping Millions of Users Make Smarter Purchases Online.

BBB Accredited Business.
SSL Secured Site.

Choosing The Best Option

What goes into being the best, you may ask. The criteria we've looked at include:

Satisfaction guarantee. Satisfaction guarantee
Extra Costs. Extra costs
Selection. Selection
Potential Savings. Potential Savings
Coupon Codes. Coupon codes
Reputation. Reputation

Car Seats Shopping Guide

Shopping for a car seat can feel like an overwhelming process, especially when 10 different moms tell you what they think is best. While you shouldn’t just buy the first car seat you see, it also shouldn’t require a PhD in Car Seat Science to find the perfect fit for your family. To begin your search, it’s helpful to know what to focus on and how to compare car seats, so we're here to help with that.

If you already know the kind of car seat you want, you can skip this and go straight to our top ten car seat picks, listed above. We’ve chosen our picks based on performance, user ratings, features, and actual comments made by parents who’ve purchased these car seats. For those who are ready to start comparing, scroll up to take a look at our top ten car seats and find your new favorite without the stress.

Four Types of Car Seats

To start, the four kinds of car seats that you’ll see are front-facing, rear-facing, booster, and convertible. These types of car seats all depend on the size, weight, and age of the child who will be using the car seat.

The first car seat you should be looking for with a newborn or infant is a rear-facing car seat, and you should be keeping your child in a rear-facing car seat for as long as their height and weight requirements allow. Each car seat will come with guidelines on maximum weight and height requirements, rather than age restrictions.

As your child grows past these weight and height limits, they can start using a front-facing car seat, then a booster, and then eventually the seat belt. When you change from a rear-facing to a front-facing seat, you’ll need to adjust straps and buckle placement to ensure that your car seat is ready for front-facing momentum.

Due to the importance of proper shoulder strap and buckle placement, you’ll need to make sure your car seat is adjustable and appropriately fits the weight and height of your child. Read the owner's manual and restrictions before making your final decision. 

Convertible car seats allow for multiple positions: rear-, front-, or booster without having to buy a new car seat. However, not all convertible car seats can function as all three of these car seats, so be sure to understand the limits and capabilities of your future purchase.

In our top picks, you’ll see several convertible car seats that can grow with your child. One of the biggest benefits of these is that you don’t need to relearn the ins and outs of a new car seat just because your kid grows out of a rear-facing position. While you’ll need to make the safety adjustments, you’ll have enough experience with your convertible car seat to know how it functions and how to work with it.

Ease of Use and Installation

What good is a car seat if you have trouble using it any time you decide to go to the grocery store? The hassle of some car seat functions can cause some parents to overlook certain adjustments, undermining safety aspects and putting your family at risk.

Safety being the number-one priority, a car seat that is intuitive and easy to adjust means that you’ll be installing the seat correctly every time you go for a car ride, ultimately resulting in a safer ride for everyone. How do you know which car seat is easy and which one is more complicated than a Rubik's Cube? Read the user reviews. Parents will not hold back on a car seat they deem hard-to-use with convoluted instructions.

It’s incredibly frustrating to have your toddler go from happy to grumpy just because you’ve taken 20 minutes to get out the car seat manual. Because of this, we wholeheartedly believe in the magic of parent reviews, especially in the world of Amazon where everything allows for a rating.

Along with this, you can typically tell how complicated a car seat will be by its adjustability functions. Some, like the Evenflo SureRide DLX Convertible Car Seat, have up-front harness adjusters that don’t require searching behind a child or fiddling with the straps under the car seat itself.

Look for keywords like “Adjuster” and multi-positioned headrests, footrests, etc. — hints like this mean that the manufacturers have prioritized simplicity into their design, not leaving you to manually change anything about the car seat.

Car Seat Portability

Portability is something that might come up last in your decision-making, but it’s important to consider where your car seat will be going. For flights or just changing vehicles, you want to make sure that your car seat can easily be transported for stress-free travel.

While most car seats are equipped with travel in mind, make sure your car seat is easy to maneuver and works well with different vehicles. You can take a look at the dimensions of the car seat to ensure that its sizing is appropriate for your car.

Even if you find the coolest, comfiest, most stylish car seat on the market, it won’t matter if you can’t fit it in your car.

Breathability and Comfort

Throughout the summer days, you might have realized how important it is to have breathable clothing or mesh-backed chairs. Without built-in ventilation in the fabric that is touching you, you’ll start to feel hot and sweaty once higher temperatures kick in.

That said, car seat fabric should also be breathable and comfortable for any little ones who are sitting in them. As car seats implement extra padding to absorb the shock of a collision, you have to take into consideration the warmth that comes from this added material.

Some manufacturers have taken this into consideration, putting breathable fabric and mesh netting into some of the material that comes in contact with children. This can be even more of a priority for folks in hotter regions, especially as you wait for that cool air from the A/C to kick in.

Editor’s Choice

Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat

The Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat tops our list as the #1 car seat available on Amazon. It’s not hard to see why Graco has received thousands of raving reviews from parents everywhere.

With its affordable pricing, Graco jam-packs features and comfort into its convertible car seat, giving it an unbeatable value that stays with you as your child grows.

Not only does Extend2Fit adjust with your child, but it also makes care and installation easy on the parents. A removable, machine-washable cover keeps you away from the car wash and allows you to bring the fabrics inside for a simple clean. Say goodbye to those annoying and cumbersome late-night car seat scrubbing sessions.

The Simply Safe Adjust Harness System is convenient and built with parents in mind. Both safe and simple, adults can make any necessary adjustment while on the go, keeping kids securely fastened in their seats, no matter what.

Add multi-point adjustments on the headrest, legroom, and recline, Store-It-All cup holders, and a Fuss-Free harness storage, and you’ve found yourself a car seat that thinks of everything.

Graco Extend2Fit isn’t our only choice in our top picks, and in the end, it boils down to what you and your family needs in terms of a new car seat. Compare and review our top 10 car seats and get a comfortable, safe, and hassle-free car seat for your family today! 

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.